Bitter aperitivo · Cane base · Made for Passover, no kitniyot

Bitter Rosso

A clone of Luxardo Bitter Rosso, rebuilt from what Luxardo declares, ten reviewers' tasting notes and the literature on each ingredient. Made with Brazilian ingredients and cane vodka, and tuned by tasting it in a Negroni.

Yield
1 L
Strength
25 % ABV
Sugar
250 g/L
Botanicals
14
Start to bottle
16 days

Ingredients · Makes 1 litre at 25%

Fraction A · roots and bark · 100 ml vodka · 14 days · do not press

  • 6 gGentian (Gentiana lutea, chopped dried root, not powdered)
  • 3 gRhubarb (Rheum palmatum, chopped dried root)
  • 0.3 gCinchona, optional (Cinchona pubescens or C. calisaya, bark, with the scientific name on the packet)

Fraction B · citrus and spice · 420 ml vodka · 7 days

  • 12 g, ≈ 2 fruitsSweet orange (Citrus sinensis, pear or bahia; fresh peel, pith removed)
  • 4 gBitter orange (Citrus aurantium, dried peel with the pith)
  • 2 g, ≈ ⅓ fruitLimão-siciliano (Citrus limon, fresh peel, pith removed)
  • 0.4 gCardamom (Elettaria cardamomum, 2–3 green pods, split open)

Fraction C · herbs · 100 ml vodka · 48 hours

  • 1.5 gWormwood (Artemisia absinthium, dried leaves and flowering tops)
  • 0.6 gMarjoram (Origanum majorana, dried)
  • 0.3 gThyme (Thymus vulgaris, dried)
  • 0.25 gMint (Mentha spicata (or peppermint, M. × piperita), dried)
  • 0.3 gRosemary (Salvia rosmarinus, dried)

Fraction D · colour · 80 + 20 ml vodka · 24 hours

  • 6 gHibiscus (Hibiscus sabdariffa, whole dried calyces, in 80 ml)
  • 0.3 gUrucum, optional (Bixa orellana, whole seeds, in 20 ml)

Assembly · per 1 L · day 14

  • 720 mlCane vodka (38–40%, with hechsher for Passover)
  • 250 gSugar (refined or granulated, plain)
  • 0.5–1 gCitric acid (with hechsher, or fresh filtered lemon juice)
  • ~200 mlWater (filtered, low-mineral)

Method ·

  1. Before · shoppingBuy and check. Check the seals against the current year's Passover list, and the scientific name of each herb on the packet. Four name traps: gentian violet is not gentian; colorau is not urucum (it carries corn flour); "losna-brava" is not wormwood; "quina" with no (Cinchona) on the packet is not cinchona. Buy the fresh fruit only on day 7. The herbs weigh in tenths of a gram, so use a 0.01 g (jeweller's) scale. Without one, make Fraction C for 4 L in 400 ml and use a quarter of it.
  2. Day 0 · 14 daysAssemble Fraction A. 6 g gentian, 3 g rhubarb and, if you have it, 0.3 g cinchona, chopped into 3–5 mm pieces, in 100 ml of vodka. Use a dark, capped jar, and shake once a day. Do not use powdered root: it clouds, will not filter and releases too much tannin from the rhubarb.
  3. Day 7 · 7 daysAssemble Fraction B. Scrub the fruit in hot water to remove the wax. Take only the coloured peel, with a peeler: the pith's limonin in the sweet orange is not masked by the sugar. 12 g orange, 2 g lemon, 4 g dried bitter orange and 0.4 g cardamom (pods split with the flat of a knife) in 420 ml of vodka.
  4. Day 12 · 48 hoursAssemble Fraction C. 1.5 g wormwood, 0.6 g marjoram, 0.3 g thyme, 0.3 g rosemary and 0.25 g mint in a voile bag, in 100 ml of vodka. 48 hours, not one more. After that comes a grassy taste, and green chlorophyll added to the red turns it brown.
  5. Day 13 · 24 hoursAssemble Fraction D. 6 g hibiscus in 80 ml of vodka. If using urucum, 0.3 g of seeds in 20 ml, in a separate jar. Do not go over 24 hours: the hibiscus turns tannic and tastes of tea.
  6. Day 14 · filterFilter and set the reserves aside. Strain each fraction through a sieve, then through a paper filter. Let Fraction A drain without pressing: pressing pushes through fine particles and tannin. Fractions B, C and D can be pressed in a cloth. Set aside 20% of A, 20% of C and 30% of D in labelled jars: that is what gets adjusted by taste. Combine the rest. Note the total volume including the reserves, and measure the blend's strength with a hydrometer. Both numbers go into the calculator.
  7. Day 14 · sweetenAssemble the batch. Dissolve the sugar and 0.5 g of citric acid in the water at room temperature, stirring for about 10 minutes, without heating. Use the amounts from the calculator. Then combine with the fractions. Taste it neat. It should be sweet and round on entry, with the bitterness arriving after.
  8. Day 14 · tasteSet the bitterness in a Negroni. Take 100 ml from the batch. Test Negroni: 20 ml gin, 20 ml vermouth, 20 ml of the bitter and 15 ml of chilled water, no ice, so the dilution is always the same. If the bitter disappears, drip 5 drops (0.25 ml) of reserve A into the 100 ml, which is equivalent to 2.5 ml per litre, and repeat the test. For more wormwood, do the same with reserve C. In the batch, use the total dripped in times 10. Top up whatever reserve is left over with the same volume of vodka, so the strength does not change. Bitterness does not come back out once it goes in. The target is "smooth and lingering", shorter than Campari's.
  9. Day 14 · colourSet the colour and acidity. In a glass, against white paper, add reserve D a little at a time until it reaches a bright, light red. Urucum pulls it toward scarlet: 1 ml at a time. If the colour pulls toward purple, the pH is high. Raise the citric acid up to 1 g per litre in total. Top up whatever D is left with vodka.
  10. Day 14–16 · 48 hoursStabilise in the cold. Leave it 48 hours in the fridge, as cold as possible, and filter through paper while still cold. Peel oils and waxes that stay dissolved when warm separate out in the cold. Filtered warm, the bitter turns cloudy in a glass with ice.
  11. Day 16 · bottleBottle it. Use amber or dark bottles, filled to the neck, and store somewhere cool. Even the original's E122 fades in light [22], and hibiscus fades faster.
  12. Day 23 · 7 daysRest and compare. A week's rest to integrate. Then make a Negroni with the clone and, if you can, another with the Luxardo or the Campari alongside it. Note what to adjust: it is the most useful data for the next batch.

Where to buy each thing

Supermarket
anywhere
sweet orange, lemon, refined sugar
Herb shop
whole, single-ingredient
gentian, rhubarb, cinchona, bitter orange, cardamom, wormwood, marjoram, thyme, mint, rosemary, hibiscus, annatto
The hard one
needs a Passover hechsher
cane vodka at 38–40% · Suppliers
The cinchona and the annatto. The cinchona is optional and stays at 0.3 g: Italian bitters measure only 1.4 to 6.9 mg/L of quinine. The annatto is optional too, to correct the hibiscus colour.
01

What is known and what is reconstruction

Luxardo declares more than it first appears. The rest comes from tasting notes and the chemistry of each ingredient, and the tags show where the known part ends.

What Luxardo declares. Strength is 25%. The bitter comes from separate infusions of bitter herbs, aromatic plants and citrus in water and alcohol, then blended, filtered and bottled. Gentian and wormwood are the flavours the company names. The 2015 product page also listed sweet orange, bitter orange, rhubarb, mint, marjoram and thyme. The spec sheet describes an aroma of "quinine and bay, lemon thyme", with "hints of spice", and a bitterness that is "smooth and lingering".

What the label and importer say. In Europe, the label lists water, sugar, alcohol, natural flavouring, citric acid and colour E122. In the US, the colour is Red 40. The Norwegian importer declares 250 g/L of sugar.

An indirect clue. According to the spec sheet, Bitter Bianco "shares the same infusions" as the Rosso, only distilled. Matteo Luxardo named cardamom, rhubarb, quinine and bitter orange among the Bianco's seven herbs. That is the best evidence that the Rosso also carries cardamom and quinine.

What is not evidence. The fifteen-item list that circulates on online shops (with woodruff, "fern" and cherry) first appears in a California shop in 2014. It mixes one reviewer's tasting notes with Luxardo's own list and does not come from the producer. There is also no published chemical analysis of this product, neither by GC-MS nor by HPLC.

Tags

Confirmed Luxardo declares it, on the page, in the spec sheet, on the label or to the importer. Inferred deduced from the infusions shared with the Bianco or from tasting notes. Substitution this project's choice, for kashrut or for availability. The tag says whether the ingredient is in the original. Doses are always an estimate.

The original is already kosher

The 2019 KLBD certificate lists Bitter 18%–25% as pareve, not Passover. If you find the bottle in Brazil with the seal, it is fine all year round. What this clone adds is Passover and buying it in Brazil.

02

Flavour profile

Descriptors from ten independent reviewers, counting copied text only once. Each descriptor traces to the compound that explains it and from there to the ingredient.

DescriptorSourcesLikely compoundIn the clone
Orangebitter, peel, blood orange8 of 10
and producer
Limonene, octanal, linalool; naringin in the pithSweet orange and bitter orange. The most cited descriptor: Luxardo is an orange bitter.
Sweet, syrupy; creamy body6 and 4 of 10Sucrose, 250 g/LSugar at 250 g/L, matching the declared figure. The "creamy" is sugar, not fat.
Spice, pepper, bay4 of 10
and spec sheet
1,8-cineole (the bay-leaf compound), α-terpinyl acetateCardamom, from the Bianco clue, and rosemary. Both are rich in cineole.
Rhubarb, earthy3 of 10
and producer
Anthraquinones, tanninsRhubarb root, at a low dose.
Less bitter than Campari3 of 5
comparisons
Less gentian and quinineHalf the gentian of our Campari, and no quassia. One source found it more bitter.
Gentian; wormwood on the finish2 of 10
and producer
Amarogentin, gentiopicroside; absinthinGentian and wormwood, the two flavours Luxardo names.
"Quinine"2 of 10
and spec sheet
Quinine, or gentian read as quinineA trace of cinchona bark, in the range measured in Italian bitters.
Lemon thyme, herbal2 of 10
and producer
Thymol; terpinen-4-ol, sabinene hydrateThyme and marjoram.
Lemon2 of 10Citral, limoneneA little limão-siciliano peel.
Mint1 of 10
and producer
Carvone or mentholMint, as a background note.
Cherry, red berries, chocolate2 and 1 of 10Probably sugar, gentian and rhubarb together, plus colour biasing the tastingNothing added. The hibiscus covers part of the red-berry note.
Fennel, anise2 of 10AnetholeLeft out: both sources trace to the same lineage of notes, and many Ashkenazim treat fennel as kitniyot.
Grapefruit1 of 10Nootkatone; a thiol with a very low thresholdDropped from the earlier version: only one source, and the compound is too strong to dose at home.
Critical reading

Difford's notes for the Luxardo and for the Campari use almost the same words (quinine, bay, lemon thyme, blood orange), and Luxardo's own spec sheet copies those notes. So they count as a single source, and cannot tell the two products apart. "Quinine" is a way of describing a type of bitterness and is not proof that the bark is in the bitter. Marjoram appears in no tasting note, but it is on the producer's list, so it stays.

03

Luxardo and Campari

They are cousins in the same category, with the same strength, almost the same sugar and the same principal colourant. The difference is in what comes forward: orange and herbs in one, earth, spice and wood in the other.

AspectLuxardo Bitter RossoCampari
Strength25% in Europe, the US and Norway20.5% to 28.5%, depending on the market; 25% in Italy
Sugar250 g/L declared to the Norwegian importer240 g/L Italian label, 24 g per 100 ml; Difford's gives 229
European labelWater, sugar, alcohol, natural flavouring, citric acid, E122Water, sugar, natural flavourings, E122, E102 and E133
ColourE122 only (Red 40 in the US). Described as "light crimson" and "light red"E122 with yellow (E102) and blue (E133) since 2006; carmine before that. "Brilliant crimson"
ProcessSeparate infusions of bitter herbs, aromatic plants and citrus, blended and filteredHerbs soaked in water and then macerated in neutral alcohol and water for about two weeks
ConfirmedEight: sweet orange, bitter orange, rhubarb, mint, marjoram, thyme, gentian, wormwoodOne: bitter orange peel
InferredCardamom and quinine, from the Bianco infusionsGentian, cascarilla, chinotto, rhubarb, ginseng, quinine. The "68 herbs" figure is marketing
ProfileOrange up front (8 of 10 reviewers), sweet and creamy, light spice, rhubarb. Less bitter and with a shorter finish than Campari in 3 of 5 comparisonsIn a panel of 25 people: bitter, earthy, herbaceous, sweet, warm spice, wood, anise. Citrus cited only 4 times [2]. Among the volatiles, limonene dominates [1]
KosherKLBD, pareve, not Passover (2019 certificate)Star-K pareve and kosher for Passover only in the batches listed for the Israeli importer (2025 letter). The regular bottle carries no seal
What that changes in the clone

Campari leans on roots, barks and woody spice (cascarilla, clove, chinotto); the orange sits on top. Luxardo is the opposite: the orange and the leaf herbs (thyme, marjoram, mint) come forward, the body is sweeter and the bitterness is shorter. That is why the clone carries fewer bittering agents than our Campari, has no cascarilla, clove or chinotto, uses cardamom as its only spice, and raises the sugar to 250 g/L.

04

Component analysis

Doses for 1 L of finished bitter, in four fractions, the way Luxardo does it. The split follows how long each group takes to extract. The numbers in brackets point to the references at the foot of the page.

Fraction A · roots and bark 100 ml vodka · 14 days · do not press

ComponentDoseFunctionWhy it is hereActive principleBasis
GentianGentiana lutea, chopped dried root, not powdered 6 g Dominant bitterness The flavour Luxardo names. With full extraction, 6 g would give 126–336 mg/L of gentiopicroside; 18 measured Italian bitters sit between 1 and 299 mg/L [3][4]. Half the dose of our Campari, because Luxardo is described as less bitter. At 40% the extraction sits close to the optimum, which is around 49% [5]. Gentiopicroside (21–56 mg/g in the root), amarogentin (bitterness index ~58 million) [4] Confirmed
RhubarbRheum palmatum, chopped dried root 3 g Earthy base On the producer's list and cited by 3 reviewers. Gives earth, light smoke and astringency under the orange. Lowered from 4 to 3 g: EFSA could not set a safe dose for the root's anthraquinones [12]. Anthraquinones (rhein, emodin), tannins Confirmed
Cinchona, optionalCinchona pubescens or C. calisaya, bark, with the scientific name on the packet 0.3 g Dry finish The "quinine" of the spec sheet and of 2 reviewers, and one of the Bianco's herbs. New. Italian bitters with cinchona measure 1.4–6.9 mg/L of quinine [3], close to the 2.5 mg/L threshold [9]. This dose sits in the same range. Without an identified bark, leave it out; the gentian covers almost everything. Quinine (about 1–3% of the bark) Inferred

Fraction B · citrus and spice 420 ml vodka · 7 days

ComponentDoseFunctionWhy it is hereActive principleBasis
Sweet orangeCitrus sinensis, pear or bahia; fresh peel, pith removed 12 g
≈ 2 fruits
Top note On the producer's list, and orange is the most cited descriptor (8 of 10). A little above what the bitter alone would need, because limonene is what the gin, the vermouth and the glass garnish have in common. Limonene (~95% of the oil), octanal, decanal, linalool Confirmed
Bitter orangeCitrus aurantium, dried peel with the pith 4 g Bitter orange and peel bitterness On the producer's list and gives the "peel bitterness" of the finish. It is the recipe's only peel bitterness: sugar masks naringin, but not the pith's limonin [11]. That is why the sweet orange goes in without the pith. Aroma: α-pinene, octanal, linalool, linalyl acetate [10]. Pith: naringin, neohesperidin Confirmed
Limão-sicilianoCitrus limon, fresh peel, pith removed 2 g
≈ ⅓ fruit
Brightness Cited by 2 reviewers. Replaces the grapefruit, which had only one source. Limonene, citral, linalool Inferred
CardamomElettaria cardamomum, 2–3 green pods, split open 0.4 g Spice New. Matteo Luxardo named cardamom among the Bianco's herbs, which share the same infusions. It explains the "spice", the "pepper" and the "bay" of the tasting notes. 1,8-cineole (25–45%), α-terpinyl acetate Inferred

Fraction C · herbs 100 ml vodka · 48 hours

ComponentDoseFunctionWhy it is hereActive principleBasis
WormwoodArtemisia absinthium, dried leaves and flowering tops 1.5 g Aromatic bitterness The flavour Luxardo names, and the reviewers' "wormwood on the finish". Raised from 1 to 1.5 g: perceived bitterness tracks the amount of wormwood [8], and thujone stays well under the limits [6][7]. It is also the direct bridge to the vermouth. Absinthin; thujone in the oil, with a safety cap Confirmed
MarjoramOriganum majorana, dried 0.6 g Floral herb; bridge to the gin On the producer's list. In the Negroni, two of its terpenes are also in juniper. Terpinen-4-ol (29–33%), cis-sabinene hydrate (20–29%) [19] Confirmed
ThymeThymus vulgaris, dried 0.3 g Phenolic note On the producer's list and is the "lemon thyme" of the notes. Kept deliberately low: next to the gin's pine, the phenol reads medicinal. Thymol (30–55% of the oil), carvacrol Confirmed
MintMentha spicata (or peppermint, M. × piperita), dried 0.25 g Freshness On the producer's list. A thread of freshness on the finish; in excess, it turns cold and fights the vermouth's spices. Carvone (spearmint) or menthol (peppermint) Confirmed
RosemarySalvia rosmarinus, dried 0.3 g Bay note and bridge to the gin Moved into the main batch. In the earlier version it sat in a separate fraction. The Bianco's notes describe herbal complexity "led by rosemary", and one Rosso reviewer names it. Its cineole adds to the "bay"; its α-pinene is juniper's main terpene. 1,8-cineole, α-pinene, camphor Inferred

The phenolics from wormwood and mint come out in the first days of maceration [20]. That is why 48 hours is enough, and any longer only brings a grassy taste.

Fraction D · colour 80 + 20 ml vodka · 24 hours

ComponentDoseFunctionWhy it is hereActive principleBasis
HibiscusHibiscus sabdariffa, whole dried calyces, in 80 ml 6 g
dose by colour
Colorant In place of E122. Raised from 4 to 6 g. Luxardo is described as "light red", so this stays below the 15 g of our Campari; more calyx brings more acidity and astringency [23]. The colour lasts longer at low pH, in the cold and in the dark [13]; extracted in stronger alcohol, it lasts longer still [14], and at 40% it fades sooner. Anthocyanins (delphinidin and cyanidin-3-sambubioside), red only at low pH Substitution
Urucum, optionalBixa orellana, whole seeds, in 20 ml 0.3 g Hue adjustment The "touch of orange" in the colour that two reviewers noted. Fades with light and acidity [17]: only worth it with a dark bottle. Bixin, an orange apocarotenoid Substitution

Assembly per 1 L · day 14

ComponentDoseFunctionWhy it is hereActive principleBasis
Cane vodka38–40%, with hechsher for Passover 720 ml
across the fractions
Solvent and strength Cane base for Passover. Aromatic macerates work best between 40% and 50% [21], and gentian extracts close to the optimum. It skips 96% alcohol, which is hard to find certified. Ethanol Substitution
Sugarrefined or granulated, plain 250 g
calculator
Sweetness and body Raised from 200 to 250 g/L, the declared figure. It is the "creamy" that four reviewers cite. Dissolve without heat: fructose from inverted sugar and furfural from heated sugar both speed up colour loss [15][16]. Sucrose Confirmed
Citric acidwith hechsher, or fresh filtered lemon juice 0.5–1 g Freshness and colour New. It is on the European label. It balances the 250 g/L, and citric acid was the additive that best protected the hibiscus anthocyanins [13]. With lemon juice: 10 ml per 0.5 g, taken out of the water. Citric acid Confirmed
Waterfiltered, low-mineral ~200 ml
calculator
Dilution Brings the batch to 25%. Holding the original's strength is part of getting the bitterness right: alcohol raises perceived bitterness [18]. — Confirmed
Left out on purpose

Grapefruit: only one source, and a compound too strong to dose at home. Cherry: no ingredient evidence; the pit and bitter almond release cyanide. Cinnamon and cassia: one reviewer, and it would double the vermouth's spice. Fennel and anise: same lineage of notes and kitniyot for many. Woodruff, orris root and angelica: one reviewer, repeated by shop listings; woodruff carries coumarin. Quassia: that is our Campari's; Luxardo calls for less bitterness. Beetroot: the colour disappears and an earthy taste shows up. Cachaça as the base: green notes the original does not have.

Safety caps, not flavour caps

Wormwood. The EU limits thujone to 35 mg/kg in Artemisia drinks, and there is a proposed acceptable intake of 0.11 mg/kg per day, about 7.7 mg for 70 kg [7]. In the most loaded plant, the practical cap is 3 g/L; the recipe uses 1.5 g. Do not use in pregnancy.

Rhubarb. Use only the root; the leaf is toxic. EFSA treats the anthraquinones as possibly genotoxic and has not set a safe dose [12]. Do not go over 4 g/L.

Cinchona. Herb-shop "quina" names bark from several species in Brazil; only use it with Cinchona on the packet. Do not go over 1 g/L, which still stays well under tonic water. Anyone who has reacted to quinine should leave it out.

Bitter orange. Use the peel, never capsule extract, which is concentrated synephrine. Gentian violet is a pharmacy antiseptic, not the root.

05

Next to our Campari

The clone set beside the two Campari reconstructions we have already made. All three use the same family of method; what changes is the target.

AspectBitter Rosso de CanaAmaro RossoAmaro Rosso Brasileiro
TargetLuxardo Bitter Rosso; NegroniCampari; neat, Americano, spritzCampari's profile; Boulevardier and Negroni
Strength and sugar25% · 250 g/L24% · 240 g/L26% · 220 g/L
Gentian6 g12 g14 g
Other bittering agentsWormwood 1.5 g; cinchona 0.3 gCinchona 0.5 g, quassia 1.5 g, wormwood 1 gCinchona 0.3 g, quassia 1.5 g, wormwood 0.5 g
Body and fixativeRhubarb 3 gRhubarb 8 g, ginseng 3 g, orris 1 gRhubarb 8 g, suma 3 g, priprioca 1.5 g
CitrusFresh sweet orange 12 g, bitter orange 4 g, lemon 2 gBitter orange 20 g, sweet 6 g, limão-cravo, kaffir, lemonLaranja-da-terra 30 g, sweet 6 g, limão-cravo, kaffir, lemon
SpiceCardamom 0.4 gCascarilla 4 g, cinnamon 1 g, cloveSacaca 5 g, cinnamon 1.5 g, clove
Leaf herbsMarjoram, thyme, mint, rosemary——
Bridge to the spiritRosemary and marjoram for the juniper—Aroeira for the juniper; amburana and baunilha for the oak
Colour and acidityHibiscus 6 g for 24 h; optional urucum; citric acidHibiscus 15 g for 3 daysHibiscus 15 g and urucum 1 g
Botanicals and time14 · 16 days + 1 week15 · 6 weeks17 · 6 weeks

The clone is the lightest of the three in bitterness and the most herbal. The Amaro Rosso is the most earthy and spiced. The Brasileiro is the most bitter and the only one with wood. That matches the originals: the panel describes Campari as earthy and herbaceous, with little citrus [2], and reviewers describe the Luxardo as orange-forward and less bitter.

Corrections applied to the Campari pages in September 2026

Quinine. The Amaro Rosso's 3 g/L of cinchona gave an estimate of tens of mg/L of quinine, near tonic water. Italian bitters measured with cinchona carry 1.4–6.9 mg/L [3]. The Amaro Rosso moved to 0.5 g, and the Brasileiro, which had 1.5 g, to 0.3 g.

Gentian. With full extraction, 12–14 g/L would give 250–780 mg/L of gentiopicroside, above the 18 measured Italian bitters (up to 299 mg/L) [3][4]. That makes sense in the Brasileiro, which has to stand up to the bourbon. In the Amaro Rosso, it is worth checking side by side against Campari.

Syrup. Both pages used to dissolve the sugar warm and now dissolve it at room temperature. That keeps the sugar from inverting or forming furfural, both of which speed up the hibiscus colour loss [15][16].

Sugar. The Amaro Rosso's 240 g/L matches Campari's Italian label.

06

Kashrut control

The bitter carries no wine, so it is the easy part of the Negroni. The problems cluster in the items nobody thinks of as an ingredient.

Base alcohol
"Grain alcohol" does not state its origin. Grain is chametz on Passover; grape distillate raises the yayin nesech question; flavoured vodka carries aroma from an unstated source.
Use cane vodka with hechsher for Passover. The BDK's 2021 Passover list, kitniyot-free, included Vodka Polak, from Cia. Müller (the same maker as 51). Check the current year's list.
Sugar
Icing sugar carries corn starch (kitniyot). Glucose syrup comes from corn or wheat. "Light" sugar has sweetener.
Use plain refined or granulated sugar. União and Guarani were on the 2021 list.
Citric acid
Comes from fermentation on corn or wheat.
Use citric acid with hechsher, for Passover on Passover, or fresh, filtered lemon juice.
Colorant
Carmine (E120, cochineal) is insect-derived and forbidden. Liquid or gel baking colour comes in glycerine, which can be animal-derived, and sometimes carries carmine. Powdered E122 is often cut with corn dextrose.
Use colour from whole plant material only: hibiscus and, if you like, urucum seeds.
Dried leaves and flowers
May carry insects. In herbs, this is the most common kashrut problem.
Use marjoram, thyme, mint and rosemary from Companhia das Ervas, which were on the 2021 list. Wormwood and hibiscus were not: buy whole leaves and calyces, examine them, macerate in a voile bag and filter through paper. Whether filtering is enough is for your rabbi to decide.
Roots, barks and cinchona bark
Powder is milled on shared equipment and can come cut with something else. For Passover, some agencies require hechsher even on raw botanicals.
Use whole or chopped roots and barks, single-ingredient, with no additive. Ask your rabbi whether unhechshered is acceptable.
Seeds: cardamom and urucum
Some authorities treat small seeds as kitniyot. I found no clear position for either one.
All year round, no problem, in whole pods and seeds. On Passover, ask your rabbi. Without cardamom, almost all the spice falls to the rosemary; without urucum, the bitter reads ruby rather than scarlet.
Essences and flavourings
The original declares "natural flavouring". At home, orange flavouring, gentian extract or "bitter essence" come in a carrier (propylene glycol, glycerine, alcohol) that never shows on the label.
Do not use them. Raw ingredients only.
Equipment
Glass, funnel and sieve that have touched liqueur, non-kosher wine or chametz.
Use new or kashered glass. New cloth, plastic and paper filters. On Passover, equipment dedicated to this alone.
Gin and vermouth
Not in the recipe, but they decide the Negroni. Vermouth is wine, so it must be kosher. Grain gin is chametz on Passover, and some gins are grape-based.
All year round: gin and vermouth your agency approves. On Passover: this house's own Gin de Cana and Vermouth Rosso de Cana, or a cane gin with hechsher for Passover and a vermouth on wine that is kosher for Passover.
Limits

Ingredient control is not certification. The final word belongs to your rabbi. The list cited is from 2021: check the current year's.

07

Method

The fractions start on different days so they finish together on day 14. A step is only struck through in the log once all its boxes are checked.

Beforeshopping

Buy and check

Check the seals against the current year's Passover list, and the scientific name of each herb on the packet. Four name traps:

  • gentian violet is not gentian;
  • colorau is not urucum (it carries corn flour);
  • "losna-brava" is not wormwood;
  • "quina" with no Cinchona on the packet is not cinchona.

Buy the fresh fruit only on day 7. The herbs weigh in tenths of a gram, so use a 0.01 g (jeweller's) scale. Without one, make Fraction C for 4 L in 400 ml and use a quarter of it.

Day 014 days

Assemble Fraction A

6 g gentian, 3 g rhubarb and, if you have it, 0.3 g cinchona, chopped into 3–5 mm pieces, in 100 ml of vodka. Use a dark, capped jar, and shake once a day.

Do not use powdered root: it clouds, will not filter and releases too much tannin from the rhubarb.

Day 77 days

Assemble Fraction B

Scrub the fruit in hot water to remove the wax. Take only the coloured peel, with a peeler: the pith's limonin in the sweet orange is not masked by the sugar.

12 g orange, 2 g lemon, 4 g dried bitter orange and 0.4 g cardamom (pods split with the flat of a knife) in 420 ml of vodka.

Day 1248 hours

Assemble Fraction C

1.5 g wormwood, 0.6 g marjoram, 0.3 g thyme, 0.3 g rosemary and 0.25 g mint in a voile bag, in 100 ml of vodka.

48 hours, not one more. After that comes a grassy taste, and green chlorophyll added to the red turns it brown.

Day 1324 hours

Assemble Fraction D

6 g hibiscus in 80 ml of vodka. If using urucum, 0.3 g of seeds in 20 ml, in a separate jar.

Do not go over 24 hours: the hibiscus turns tannic and tastes of tea.

Day 14filter

Filter and set the reserves aside

Strain each fraction through a sieve, then through a paper filter. Let Fraction A drain without pressing: pressing pushes through fine particles and tannin. Fractions B, C and D can be pressed in a cloth.

Set aside 20% of A, 20% of C and 30% of D in labelled jars: that is what gets adjusted by taste. Combine the rest. Note the total volume including the reserves, and measure the blend's strength with a hydrometer. Both numbers go into the calculator.

Day 14sweeten

Assemble the batch

Dissolve the sugar and 0.5 g of citric acid in the water at room temperature, stirring for about 10 minutes, without heating. Use the amounts from the calculator. Then combine with the fractions.

Taste it neat. It should be sweet and round on entry, with the bitterness arriving after.

Day 14taste

Set the bitterness in a Negroni

Take 100 ml from the batch. Test Negroni: 20 ml gin, 20 ml vermouth, 20 ml of the bitter and 15 ml of chilled water, no ice, so the dilution is always the same.

If the bitter disappears, drip 5 drops (0.25 ml) of reserve A into the 100 ml, which is equivalent to 2.5 ml per litre, and repeat the test. For more wormwood, do the same with reserve C. In the batch, use the total dripped in times 10. Top up whatever reserve is left over with the same volume of vodka, so the strength does not change.

Bitterness does not come back out once it goes in. The target is "smooth and lingering", shorter than Campari's.

Day 14colour

Set the colour and acidity

In a glass, against white paper, add reserve D a little at a time until it reaches a bright, light red. Urucum pulls it toward scarlet: 1 ml at a time.

If the colour pulls toward purple, the pH is high. Raise the citric acid up to 1 g per litre in total. Top up whatever D is left with vodka.

Day 14–1648 hours

Stabilise in the cold

Leave it 48 hours in the fridge, as cold as possible, and filter through paper while still cold. Peel oils and waxes that stay dissolved when warm separate out in the cold.

Filtered warm, the bitter turns cloudy in a glass with ice.

Day 16bottle

Bottle it

Use amber or dark bottles, filled to the neck, and store somewhere cool. Even the original's E122 fades in light [22], and hibiscus fades faster.

Day 237 days

Rest and compare

A week's rest to integrate. Then make a Negroni with the clone and, if you can, another with the Luxardo or the Campari alongside it. Note what to adjust: it is the most useful data for the next batch.

08

Batch calculator

Enter the filtered volume of the four fractions combined, with the reserves, and the strength measured before the sugar. The calculator gives the sugar and the water.

Sugar
250g
Water
200ml
Final volume
998ml
700 ml bottles
1.4
Correction for a later addition

Every 10 ml of 40% fraction added after sweetening, such as redone colour weeks later, calls for 4 g of sugar and 3.5 ml of water to hold 25% and 250 g/L. Below 20 ml per litre, the difference sits inside the hydrometer's margin of error. Always measure the strength before the sugar: a hydrometer cannot read a sweetened mix.

09

In the Negroni

The original is already a Negroni bitter. The clone only reinforces the compounds the gin and the vermouth carry, and cuts the ones that fight them.

PartnerWhat it hasThe bitter reinforcesThe bitter cuts
GinLondon dry Juniper: α-pinene, sabinene, terpinen-4-ol, myrcene. Coriander: linalool. Peels: limonene Rosemary (α-pinene); marjoram (sabinene, terpinen-4-ol); orange (limonene, linalool) Thyme kept low: its thymol, a phenolic, fights the pine
Red vermouthon kosher wine 130–160 g/L sugar; wormwood, gentian, bitter orange, vanilla, clove, cinnamon Wormwood, gentian and bitter orange, the same as in the recipe No cinnamon or cassia; mint kept low
Orange peelin the glass Limonene, octanal, decanal Sweet orange, a little above what is strictly needed —
Negroni

30 ml gin, 30 ml red vermouth and 30 ml of the bitter. Stir with ice for 20–30 seconds, strain over a large ice cube and twist an orange peel over the top.

If you prefer a drier drink, make the next batch at 220 g/L. With a vermouth under 130 g/L of sugar, keep the 250.

Americano

The service from Luxardo's spec sheet: 45 ml bitter, 45 ml red vermouth and 2 dashes of aromatic bitters, topped with soda water. Garnish with a lemon peel. Use aromatic bitters only with hechsher; on Passover, leave it out.

The kosher Negroni depends on the other two bottles. The vermouth needs hechsher and, if it is not mevushal, the handling rule for kosher wine after opening applies. I have not checked which kosher vermouths reach Brazil.

10

Troubleshooting

By what you notice, which is how the problem shows up.

In the Negroni, the bitter disappears and the vermouth takes over
Not enough bitterness. Add reserve A in steps of 2.5 ml per litre.
Long, harsh bitterness, like Campari's
Too much gentian or wormwood for the target. Bitterness does not come out: the only fix is diluting with a fresh batch made without A and without C. Prevent it by raising the reserve slowly.
Metallic, dry finish
Too much cinchona. Check that it was 0.3 g, not the 3 g of the Amaro Rosso's old version.
Medicinal or mouthwash taste next to the gin
Thymol from the thyme, or menthol if you used peppermint. No fix for this batch; next time, cut the herb by half.
Camphor or eucalyptus dominating
Too much cineole: cardamom or rosemary. Next batch, cut back whichever was heavier, or halve both.
Grassy or green-tea taste; colour turning brown
Herbs over 48 hours: chlorophyll and tannin. No fix, only prevention.
Purple or dark-wine colour instead of red
pH too high for the anthocyanins. Raise the citric acid up to 1 g per litre, or use more reserve D, which is acidic.
The colour faded to brick after weeks
Light and heat degrade anthocyanin and bixin. Prevent it with a dark bottle, a cool spot and small batches. To fix it, make a fresh Fraction D and blend it in, with the correction from section 08. In the Negroni, the vermouth hides much of the loss.
Cloudy in the fridge or in a glass with ice
Peel oils and waxes. Chill again for 48 hours and filter while still cold.
Smell of stale orange, cooked marmalade
Peel macerated too long, the fruit was old, or pith from the sweet orange got in. No fix, only prevention.
Weak orange, no freshness
Too little peel, or waxed or old fruit. Macerate 12 g of fresh peel in 50 ml of vodka for 48 hours and blend it in, with the correction from section 08.
Sickly, too sweet neat
250 g/L is the original's sugar level. If you do not like it, make the next batch at 220 g/L; for this one, an extra 0.5 g/L of citric acid helps.
Earth and smoke dominating
Powdered rhubarb, or above the dose. Next batch, 3 g chopped.